This Is the Absolute Best Bakery in NYC!

2023: Manhattan Voted La Cabra Best Bakery!

La Cabra
152 2nd Avenue
lacabra.dk/pages/new-york

Though only in New York for a few years, La Cabra has captivated locals with its European-style coffee and baked goods. The bakery opened in Denmark in 2012, and the coffee shop opened in 2015. However, this gourmet bakery brand only made its New York City debut more recently. Even still, New Yorkers have already jumped on the craze of these meticulously- and thoughtfully-made breads and sweets. One look at the La Cabra bakery’s Instagram page, @lacabrabakery, and you’ll see what we mean — everything looks absolutely perfect. The croissant is a particular favorite among loyal customers, who not only voted La Cabra the best bakery in New York City, but also the establishment with the best croissants, making it a must-try when you’re in the East Village.

2022: Manhattan Voted Black Star Bakery & Cafe Best Bakery!

Black Star Bakery & Cafe
1597 York Avenue
(646) 726-4546 – blackstarbakery.com

Looking for a morning coffee? A nice pastry to start your day? A healthy protein-filled meal? Black Star Bakery & Cafe has you covered. Located on the Upper East Side, this cafe ambitiously takes on a full breakfast menu, while sticking to the basics as well as anybody. The ingredients used in all their food — from bagels to burritos — are as fresh as you could ask for. And when you’re looking to relax, the quaint inside and lovely outdoor seating provide the perfect place to settle down and do some work, read a book, or simply people watch. Take in the aroma of freshly baked and amazingly brewed coffee, and visit Black Star Bakery & Cafe today!

2021: Manhattan Voted Veniero’s Pasticceria & Cafe Best Bakery (Tie)!

Veniero’s Pasticceria & Cafe
342 E 11th St
(212) 674-7070 –http://www.venierospastry.com

Veniero’s Pasticceria & Cafe was established in 1894 by Antonio Veniero, who served his Italian pastries and cakes that won him awards in Rome, Bolognia, and at the New York World’s Fair. 157 years later, the pastry shop and cafe has many of its original details, including hand stamped metal ceilings, specially designed etched glass doors, highly polished wood mirrors and ornate marble floors. Upon entering the pastry shop, dessert lovers are greeted by a display of traditional and regional Italian confections, from creamy cannolis and cupcakes to handmade Italian butter cookies. Take in the aroma of freshly baked biscotti as well as the traditional cheesecakes and specialty cakes. We promise you’ll be coming back regularly for a box to go!

2021: Manhattan Voted Breads Bakery Best Bakery (Tie)!

Breads Bakery
18 E 16th St
(212) 633-2253 – www.breadsbakery.com

When New Yorkers are looking to satiate their sweet tooths, they look no further than Breads bakery, which serves up the finest freshly baked breads, cakes, cookies and pastries in New York City. Located in the heart of Union Square, Breads is the quintessential Manhattan bakery, replete with unrivaled sourdough, a chocolate babka to write home about and deluxe gourmet coffee and espresso that will set you right on your feet. If you are in the market for a light lunch, Breads serves that a well, alongside their handmade loaves of bread and delectable pastry treats. Send Breads fare as a gift for your loved ones or hire them to cater your next party. Every bite of their signature flavors will satisfy your soul the way only great bread can.

2020: Manhattan Voted Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe Best Bakery!

Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe
342 E 11th St
(212) 674-7070 – www.venierospastry.com

Having just past its 120th anniversary, Veniero’s Pasticceria & Cafe was established in 1894 by its founder, Antonio Veniero, who served his Italian pastries and cakes that won him awards in Rome, Bolognia, and at the New York World’s Fair. Today, the pastry shop and cafe has many of its original details, including hand stamped metal ceilings, specially designed etched glass doors, highly polished wood mirrors, and ornate marble floors. Upon entering the pastry shop, dessert lovers are greeted by a display of traditional and regional Italian confections, a vast variety of large and miniature pastries, and assortments of handmade Italian butter cookies. Take in the aroma of freshly baked biscotti as well as the traditional cheesecakes and specialty cakes.

How the Contest Works

Step 1: Nominate
Nominate your favorite Manhattan businesses. During this period you can make as many nominations as you like. The top 10 - 15 nominees make the ballot for you to vote.Nominations can be made here.

Step 2: Voting
During the voting period, you can vote once per day per category..

Step 3: Winner's Announced
At the end of the voting period, the nominee with the most votes is named Bethpage Best of the City, and holds the honor for a full year until the next winner is announced. Winners can be viewed here.

For full detailsplease see our terms and conditions

This Is the Absolute Best Bakery in NYC! - Best of the City (2024)